“Finders Keepers”

They never found the body. How could they? She was all scream. Sonic, he called her, and she sped off running through the yard in untied purple and white sneakers. Sonic, said the neighbor again, as though he could name her, too, as though the video game he’d lured her over to play was actually a pet name for her or some joke between them. 

She ran so fast she had to spit to keep breathing. Her mother, she thought, was calling her real name. I should turn around. No, thank you. It’s easier—hide and seek—with no body. A game she can win. I’m a real gingerbread boy, she thought. It was raining. The rain was wet and cold and sliding down the dirty locked car she was hiding behind, soaking through her jeans until her thighs, knees, even her shins were wet with rain. 

When she did go back home, her shoelaces were heavy with mud and trailing behind her, teasing her: Tie your shoes, why don’t you? Silly girl, you’ll trip. Inside, she took a ballpoint pen to the inside of her thigh, just to see what would happen. That’s ugly, she thought, I’m so sorry. 

She’s an adult now. She still has neighbors, but they call her whatever she tells them her name is, and she screens them at the door. A screen door. You could come in, she says, but don’t. 

Now she is old, maybe eleven or twelve years away from being ancient. She is funny, sometimes sardonic. She regularly stops smoking. Her body is hers—wrinkly and arthritic, round, plodding, and, most importantly, unrecognizable. Friends come over. She goes to see them, too. On the beige carpet in front of the big TV, a grandchild plays Sonic. The blue hedgehog, the game of it, those sneakers, the incessant music. 

“Don’t play that!” 

“Why not?” 

“Why not?!” She prepares to insist, make the child turn off the game, go outside and play, choreograph something, finish that puzzle you started, clean up lunch! But then, the body is gone again and for a moment the scream is gone, too. She disappears, lets the child play.

Related Posts
Filter by
Post Page
Featured Fiction Why I Write Most Popular The Story Behind the Story Essays/Articles (all) New Fiction
Sort by

“Sanibel Blues”

I race across the dark sand toward the distant sound of surf.  It is not yet dawn, and today I’m after a ju
2011-04-25 04:29:13


“The Fog is a Snow Leopard Eating Owslowski”

The snow leopard hasn’t been fed. The boy was in a suitcase. The children hid beneath their d
2020-05-07 12:55:22


Why I Write: Wei-Chih Eudela

The action or even the idea of being rejected evokes some pain, especially mental and emotional, for those who
2020-04-20 10:28:01


Why I Write: Allie Blum

My Motivations for Writing: A Letter to My Writing Workshop On Monday night I had trouble falling asleep. I
2020-04-13 09:15:03


The Story Behind the Story: “The Only Song is the Song of the Self”

This story is a fictionalized version of an experience I had in New York on 29 June 2008. After watching Spain beat
2020-03-31 20:08:08


“Holy Water”

DeWitt and I were swimming in his backyard when Elizabeth came over.  Elizabeth Perryman, she was a whole
2020-03-16 14:53:16


“Family In Flames”

He lived in the burning house, frantic, for fifteen years. He kept trying to tell his parents the whole place was on
2020-02-24 13:55:39



I. They stand side by side facing a row of dining room cabinets. Audrey examines each one carefully, looking
2020-02-17 07:43:02


“The Love for Writing”

I do not know why, but I do not see any demarcation line between classics and pulp fiction: both are, in my opinion,
2020-02-14 09:33:54


“A Song From The 70s”

My brother Dan and I were at the amusement park the last day it was open. It was pretty sad, actually. Only half the
2019-12-16 10:56:56


About Annie Mountcastle

Annie Mountcastle has an MFA in Creative Writing from Hollins University. She lives in Durham, North Carolina where she works in marketing and development at Durham County Library. She won The Greensboro Review's 2012 Robert Watson Literary Prize in Fiction. Her work has also appeared in Oxford Magazine and Rattle, and she was a top-25 finalist in Glimmer Train’s January 2015 Very Short Fiction Contest and their November/December 2018 Family Matters Contest. She received a 2018 Ella Fountain Pratt Emerging Artist Grant from the Durham Arts Council with support from the North Carolina Arts Council, a division of the Department of Natural & Cultural Resources, which made the project published here possible.